Written by Jim Holden.
Originally split into two parts, Peter Jackson’s epic, although based on a much shorter book than the previous Jackson-filmed The Lord of the Rings (2001-2003), has ballooned into three films. The first two parts stand at nearly three hours each, and we shall expect the concluding part, There and Back Again, to have a similar running time. From a cynical perspective, this very much seems like a studio trying to make more money from an established, built-in audience, especially as Jackson and co-writer (and once director) Guillermo Del Toro originally planned the film to be divided into (only) two parts. This scepticism became apparent after the first Hobbit film, as An Unexpected Journey (2012) was, amongst others things, long and drawn out, and seemed to concur with this stance, making the second film an even more redundant exercise, as the first part rarely captured the same sense of adventure and wonder of Jackson’s first Lord of the Rings film The Fellowship of the Ring (2001). More worrying, An Unexpected Journey felt stretched, laboured and slightly directionless, as Jackson simply just put everything he had filmed on the screen. However, The Desolation of Smaug manages, in the most part at least, to dispel that theory as the film is both an improvement on part one and a rather good film on its own terms.
This is, after all, a world in which he has been involved for fifteen or so years. The Desolation of Smaug feels like it is made by a filmmaker who knows his craft, and although we can never get past the fact that this is a middle chapter as the film simply starts, and then, conveniently, ends on a cliffhanger, in between it manages to both expand its world enough to keep the film fresh and have its protagonists experience and learn new depths, dangers, allowing the character development to evolve. Whilst the extended scenes with Bilbo and Smaug the dragon, in which Bilbo repeatedly challenges and hides from Smaug, have echoes of his face off with Gollum in An Unexpected Journey and the earlier Lord of the Rings films, it is done in a clever, gripping, and even witty way that justifies both the length of the sequence and that of the film as a whole. In fact, this sequence actually holds the film together and gives it a real purpose and grounding. This is the crux of the plot; the politics and debates are about Smaug, so it is important to give the character a chance to actually be seen and explored. It also potentially sets up a fascinating opening to part three with Smaug’s anger of awakening.
This also demonstrates why there is so much depth of character and plot throughout the series, though predominantly in the first part, as, in theory, we are committed to three films. This, then, places additional pressure on the second film, both artistically and commercially. Like The Two Towers, The Desolation of Smaug is bigger and looser than what has gone before it, and the plots somewhat echo each other. Once again our band of heroes has been split up (once again, Gandalf goes missing), and individual journeys take centre stage.
Whilst The Desolation of Smaug will be hard to judge completely until There and Back Again is released at Christmas and we can see the trilogy as a whole, it has enough, certainly for fans, to enjoy and admire. And whilst The Hobbit will never rival The Lord of the Rings for scope, adventure, emotion or even the technical brilliance, The Desolation of Smaug goes a long way toward bridging that gap. Now we just have to hold on for part three with hope. This Alternate Take was published on February 10, 2014. Post your views Article comments powered by Disqus |
Share this article Tweet Special FX - Jump to the comments - Print friendly format - Email article to a friend Similar articles - How to Train Your Dragon 2: Alternate Take - How to Train Your Dragon 2 - The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo: Alternate Take - The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo - King Kong More from this writer - Devil's Knot: Alternate Take - Devil's Knot - Girl Most Likely: Alternate Take - Girl Most Likely - This is The End: Alternate Take |